Why Being the Steady Rock Can Cost More Than You Realize
You’re the one people rely on when things are unraveling. You hold space when others panic. You show up with composure, clear voice, measured presence. On the surface, it looks like leadership, resilience—you’re the “calm one.”
But underneath that calm may live a different story: chronic tension, suppressed anxiety, emotional invisibility and accumulating cost. For high-achieving women in high-stakes careers, being the calm anchor can become a role that’s as exhausting as it is unnoticed. In this article I’ll explore how that role develops, why it’s especially common in your world, how it shows up in mind, body and relationships—and how you can begin to reclaim real regulation, not just perform calm.
How the Role of “Calm One” Takes Shape
1. Early-Life & Career Conditioning
From childhood or early career you may have learned: “Stay composed; don’t make waves; keep things together so we’re safe.” This message gets reinforced in professional settings where being reliable under pressure is rewarded. Being the calm one becomes your badge and your blind spot.
2. The Performance of Calm
In high-stakes environments, emotional arousal may be penalised—even if the reality is chaotic. You adopt neutrality, poise, smoothness. Yet what appears calm may actually be a finely-tuned control of internal systems: scanning, assessing, readying alertness—but externally still “quiet.” Some writing calls this “The high cost of calm”:
“The human nervous system requires a deceptively simple ingredient for calm — a sense of safety. … The cost of constant vigilance is high, not merely exhausting for us but actually corrosive in ways ranging from stiffening veins to hollowing out memory.” (Psychology Today)
What looks like calm may be chronic vigilance.
3. Invisible Emotional Labour
As the calm one you absorb others’ stress, moderate conflict, anticipate needs, regulate the tone of the room. That’s invisible labour—and often unrecognised. You may be doing more than shows up on your job description.
4. Suppression of Activation ≠ Regulation
Calm doesn’t always mean your nervous system is at ease. You may be suppressing arousal (emotions, thoughts) to maintain steadiness. But suppression leads to internal load: elevated sympathetic tone, diminished parasympathetic recovery, emotional constriction. Chronic suppression is linked to health impacts. Research on chronic stress shows that persistent high alertness (“vigilance”) without adequate recovery leads to mood disorder, immune dysregulation, cognitive fatigue. (PMC)
Why High-Achieving Women Especially Take on the Calm-Anchor Role
- Visibility & Scarcity: In environments where women are fewer, being the calm reliable person becomes your implicit brand. You stand out—and often carry more of the emotional upkeep.
- Perfectionism + Responsibility: Your competence means you’re trusted with the high-pressure moments—and you learn to step into the calm role because you can. But you may also believe you must.
- Emotional Labour Expectations: Women often get assigned relational or emotional stabilising tasks (“make sure the team stays ok,” “you smooth the conflict,” “you’re good with people”). These load-up the calm role.
- Masking Vulnerability: Showing stress, doubt, confusion may feel risky. So you adopt calm as your armouring, which ironically cuts off the support you might need.
The Hidden Costs: What It Looks Like When Being the Calm One Undermines You
- Physical & Somatic Markers: Persistent tightness, shallow breathing, elevated heart rate, difficulty “switching off.” Your body may stay in high-gear even when the moment has passed.
- Emotional Numbing or Flatness: You might say: “I know I did well—but I don’t feel it.” You may struggle to access joy, to feel excitement, or to sense your own fatigue until it’s severe.
- Cognitive Load & Burnout Risk: The constant internal monitoring (“How do I stay composed? What are others feeling? What is the underlying risk?”) uses cognitive resources. Over time, performance may suffer.
- Relational Disconnect: Others may lean on you constantly; you become the steady presence but not necessarily seen as a full person with needs. You may struggle to ask for help or show your inner state.
- Hidden Vulnerability to Stress-Related Disorders: Chronic high demand + low visible distress = higher risk of suppressed stress being untreated. Research shows psychosocial stressors affect mood disorders, immune functioning, and physiological health. (PMC)
What You Can Do: Releasing the Anchor to Heal the System
1. Recognise the role you’ve adopted
Ask yourself: “When did I become the calm one? What did that mean for me? How much of my energy goes into holding that role rather than being held?” Awareness helps you begin to shift.
2. Practice true calm, not just performance of calm
True calm means your nervous system also signals rest, safety, repair. Practices such as mindfulness, body scanning, breath regulation activate the parasympathetic system. The Attention Restoration Theory suggests even environmental shifts (nature exposure) assist recovery. (Greater Good)
3. Rebalance emotional labour & delegation
Notice where you absorb the emotional/regulative work. Where can it be distributed? Who else can carry team emotional climate? Boundaries matter: you don’t have to always be the anchor.
4. Request relational support not just operational support
You may have gotten good at asking for resources, staffing, outcomes. Now also ask: “How are we doing emotionally? How is our team’s nervous system? What is our culture of repair?”
5. Shift identity from “I must remain calm” to “I can allow reactivity and repair”
Being calm is not the same as being resilient. Resilience includes rise–rest–recover cycles. Authentic leadership includes showing humanity, not only poise.
6. Cultivate repair rituals
Create consistent practices for transition: ending a high-stress meeting, a large project, a crisis. Pause, check in with your body, reclaim your breath, integrate the experience. Without ritual the next “calm performance” begins immediately.
7. Seek therapy/consultation with a trauma-/performance-informed lens
Working with a professional who understands high-stakes performance, emotional labour and nervous-system regulation helps you shift from merely surviving to thriving with authenticity.
Closing Thoughts
Being the calm one is a gift—your presence offers stability, reliability, resilience. But when calm becomes a role more than a state, when you’re constantly performing composure rather than resting into peace—that gift comes at a cost. High-achieving women in high-stakes careers deserve to not just look steady, but to feel safe, regulated, connected, and seen.
If you find yourself always being the calm anchor, while your body hums with unease, your mind holds extra space, and your personal needs go unmet—you don’t have to carry that alone. Ready to move from “calm performance” to regulated presence, from anchor-mode to full-self-mode? Book your first session today, and let’s explore how you can lead with clarity and composure and humanity, resilience and rest.
Book your appointment here
Works Cited
Schneiderman, N., Ironson, G., & Siegel, S. D. (2005). STRESS AND HEALTH: Psychological, Behavioral, and Biological Determinants. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 1, 607-628. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.clinpsy.1.102803.144141. (PMC)
The High Cost of Calm. (2021, May 4). Psychology Today. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/articles/202105/the-high-cost-calm. (Psychology Today)
George, E. L. (2024, May 31). Psychological Effects of Stress. MentalHelp.net. Retrieved from https://www.mentalhealth.com/library/psychological-effects-of-stress. (MentalHealth.com)
Newman, K. M. (2021, April 22). Calm a Distressed Mind by Changing Your Environment. Greater Good Science Center. Retrieved from https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/calm_a_distressed_mind_by_changing_your_environment. (Greater Good)
